Casper vs Beautyrest: Which Brand Should You Buy in 2026?

Choosing between Casper and Beautyrest comes down to how you want to sleep and how you like to shop. Casper sells foam and hybrid mattresses online with a 100-night trial and a 10-year limited warranty. Beautyrest builds innerspring and hybrid mattresses around its Pocketed Coil technology, also with a 100-night trial and a 10-year mattress warranty. Both brands ship free and offer financing. The real differences show up in feel, construction, and the range of firmness options each one offers.

If you want a simple foam mattress with a medium-firm feel at a lower entry price, Casper is the easier buy. If you want a traditional innerspring feel with a wide ladder of firmness choices, from extra firm to plush, Beautyrest gives you more to choose from.

A strong alternative

Saatva Classic an innerspring mattress with three comfort levels and a dual-coil design

• 365-night home trial, twice the 100-night trial both Casper and Beautyrest list
• Free white-glove delivery with in-room setup and free old-mattress removal
• Lifetime warranty for the original purchaser
• Choose Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, or Firm, plus two mattress heights

Check today’s Saatva price →

Which brand should you buy, Casper or Beautyrest?

Casper is the better pick for shoppers who want a foam or hybrid mattress with a simple lineup and a medium to medium-firm feel. Beautyrest is the better pick for shoppers who want a coil-based mattress and a wide firmness range, from extra firm to plush. Both brands list a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty, so the decision comes down to feel and construction, not policy.

Casper organizes its mattresses into three families: The Foams, The Hybrids, and The Maxes. Feel options run from medium-soft to medium-firm, with one medium option in the hybrid line. Beautyrest organizes its catalog by collection, including the Beautyrest Signature Collection, the Beautyrest World Class Premier Collection, and Beautyrest Black. Its firmness filters include extra firm, firm, medium, medium-firm, and plush, so there is a wider ladder to climb.

Both brands sell direct online with free shipping, a trial period, and financing. Casper lists free no-contact delivery, an optional white glove delivery service, and a 100-night trial. Beautyrest lists a 100-night trial, free shipping and returns, white glove delivery, free mattress removal, and monthly financing.

How do Casper and Beautyrest compare on feel and support?

Casper’s lineup centers on foam feels described as medium-firm, medium, and medium-soft. The One, Casper’s signature foam mattress, is described as medium-firm with three layers of cradling foam. Beautyrest’s lineup centers on coil feels, with firmness filters spanning extra firm, firm, medium, medium-firm, and plush. Beautyrest says each coil system promotes immediate comfort and support for back, stomach, and side sleepers.

Casper describes its Dream hybrid as pairing responsive springs with ergonomic support zones, and its Dream Max as combining pressure-relieving foam, ergonomic zoning, and responsive coils. Beautyrest describes its mattresses as standing above 13 inches, with softness options in ultra plush, medium firm, and extra firm across its collections.

Neither brand publishes a single firmness number on a shared scale in the pages we have here, so a direct number-to-number comparison is not possible. What you can compare is the range: Casper offers three feels across foam and hybrid builds, while Beautyrest offers five firmness categories across innerspring and hybrid builds. Shoppers who know they want a very firm or very plush feel will find more options in the Beautyrest catalog.

If you are still weighing foam against coils, our best hybrid mattresses guide covers both construction types side by side.

What materials does each brand use?

Casper builds with foam and, in its hybrid lines, springs. The One uses three layers of cradling foam. The Dream hybrid pairs responsive springs with ergonomic support zones. The Snow line pairs conforming memory foam with encased coils and includes a QuickCool cover with cool-to-the-touch fibers. Beautyrest builds around its exclusive Pocketed Coil technology and premium materials, with breathable memory foams described as helping the body maintain its ideal thermal temperature.

Casper’s Snow and Snow Max lines add cooling features: the Snow mattress is described as attacking overheating for 12-plus hours, and Snow Max combines enhanced Snow technology with the QuickCool cover. Beautyrest describes its memory foams as breathable and its coil systems as supporting all sleep positions. Neither brand publishes a full material spec sheet on the pages reviewed here, so shoppers who want detailed layer-by-layer breakdowns should check each brand’s product pages.

For shoppers whose main concern is foam feel and pressure relief, our best memory foam mattresses list is a useful next step.

Side-by-side comparison: Casper vs Beautyrest

The differences are in what you get at delivery: Beautyrest lists free mattress removal as standard, while Casper lists optional white glove delivery.

Who should buy Casper, and who should buy Beautyrest?

Casper is for shoppers who want a foam or hybrid mattress with a simple, clearly named lineup and a medium to medium-firm feel. Its signature foam mattress, The One, is described as medium-firm with three layers of cradling foam, and the Snow line adds cooling features for hot sleepers. Casper lists a 100-night trial and a 10-year limited warranty, with free no-contact delivery and optional white glove delivery.

Beautyrest lists firmness filters for extra firm, firm, medium, medium-firm, and plush, and its collections include the Beautyrest Signature Collection and Beautyrest Black. Beautyrest says each mattress stands above 13 inches and lists a 100-night trial, a 10-year mattress warranty, free shipping and returns, white glove delivery, and free mattress removal.

Buy Casper if you prefer foam feel, want a cooling-focused model, or like a short, clearly organized lineup. Buy Beautyrest if you want a traditional innerspring feel, need a very firm or very plush option, or want free mattress removal included with delivery. If you want a firm build for stomach sleeping, our best firm mattresses guide is a good companion read.

What about hot sleepers?

Casper’s Snow and Snow Max lines are the brand’s answer for hot sleepers. The Snow mattress pairs conforming memory foam with encased coils and a QuickCool cover, and Casper describes it as attacking overheating for 12-plus hours. Snow Max adds enhanced Snow technology and the QuickCool cover with cool-to-the-touch fibers.

Neither brand publishes independent cooling test results on the pages reviewed here, so shoppers who sleep very hot should compare the specific cooling features of each model rather than rely on a headline number. Our best cooling mattresses roundup covers more options in this category.

What are the trial and warranty terms?

The trial lengths are equal, and the warranty lengths are equal, so neither brand has an advantage on paper. Both brands list free shipping, and both list financing options.

The delivery experience differs slightly. Casper lists free no-contact delivery with optional white glove delivery available. Shoppers who want their old mattress taken away at no extra cost will find that listed with Beautyrest.

For a longer trial and a longer warranty, the Saatva Classic lists a 365-night home trial and a lifetime warranty for the original purchaser, with free white-glove delivery that includes in-room setup and free old-mattress removal.

Who should NOT buy Casper or Beautyrest?

Skip Casper if you want a very firm or very plush feel, since its lineup centers on medium-firm, medium, and medium-soft. Skip Beautyrest if you want a pure foam feel without coils, since its catalog is built around Pocketed Coil technology. Also skip both brands if you want a trial longer than 100 nights or a warranty longer than 10 years, since both brands list the same 100-night trial and 10-year warranty.

Shoppers who want a longer trial and a lifetime warranty should look at the Saatva Classic, which lists a 365-night home trial, a lifetime warranty, and free white-glove delivery with in-room setup and free old-mattress removal. The Saatva Classic is available in three comfort levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm, and in two heights.

Is there a strong alternative to both Casper and Beautyrest?

Yes. The Saatva Classic is an innerspring mattress with a dual-coil design made of triple-tempered recycled carbon steel, a 3-inch Euro pillow top, and patented Lumbar Zone technology.

The Saatva Classic is CertiPUR-US certified, GREENGUARD Gold certified, and endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association. It pairs with a foundation, box spring, bunkie board, platform bed frame, or adjustable base, depending on height. If you want a longer trial, a lifetime warranty, and a choice of three comfort levels, the Saatva Classic is a strong alternative to both Casper and Beautyrest.

For more on the Saatva Classic, read our Saatva Classic review.

World Sleep Almanac score

World Sleep Almanac score: 8.7/10 for the Casper vs Beautyrest comparison.

• Trial and warranty: 9/10. Both Casper and Beautyrest list a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty, matching terms that keep either brand a straightforward buy on policy.
• Materials and construction: 8/10. Casper builds with foam and hybrid coils, while Beautyrest builds around Pocketed Coil technology with breathable memory foams.
• Comfort options: 9/10. Three feels from Casper and five firmness categories from Beautyrest give shoppers a wide range across the two brands.

This is an editorial score based on the criteria above, not a product test.

Frequently asked questions

Is Casper or Beautyrest better for side sleepers?

Both brands offer options that can work for side sleepers. Casper’s lineup includes medium-soft feels, and Beautyrest’s firmness filters include plush and medium. Neither brand publishes a side-sleeping-specific recommendation on the reviewed pages, so the best choice depends on which feel you prefer.

Do Casper and Beautyrest come with free delivery?

Both brands list free shipping. Casper lists free no-contact delivery with optional white glove delivery available. Beautyrest lists free shipping and returns, white glove delivery, and free mattress removal.

How long can I try a Casper or Beautyrest mattress at home?

Both brands list a 100-night trial. Casper calls it a 100-night trial, and Beautyrest lists a 100-night trial. The trial lengths are equal.

Does either brand offer a lifetime warranty?

No. Casper lists a 10-year limited warranty, and Beautyrest lists a 10-year mattress warranty. For a lifetime warranty, the Saatva Classic lists a lifetime warranty for the original purchaser.

Which brand is better for hot sleepers?

Casper’s Snow and Snow Max lines include cooling features such as the QuickCool cover with cool-to-the-touch fibers, and Casper describes the Snow mattress as attacking overheating for 12-plus hours.

Can I finance a Casper or Beautyrest mattress?

Yes. Both brands list financing options. Casper lists quick, simple financing options, and Beautyrest lists monthly financing.

Verdict: Casper is the better buy for shoppers who want a foam or hybrid mattress with a medium to medium-firm feel and a simple lineup. Beautyrest is the better buy for shoppers who want a coil-based mattress with a wide firmness range and free mattress removal. If you want a longer trial and a lifetime warranty, the Saatva Classic is a strong alternative.

A strong alternative

Saatva Classic a strong alternative to Casper and Beautyrest

• 365-night home trial
• Free white-glove delivery and old-mattress removal
• Lifetime warranty
• Three comfort levels and two heights

Check today’s Saatva price →

Reviewed by the World Sleep Almanac editorial team. Updated October 2026.