The Puffy Mattress and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid are two of the most talked-about online mattresses, and they take opposite routes to comfort. Puffy is a pure memory foam build with a medium-firm feel and a cradling, body-adapting character, while the Signature Hybrid pairs pressure-relieving foam with an encased coil system for a more responsive, lifted feel. The right choice comes down to whether you want to sink into foam or sleep on top of a spring system, and how much you care about choosing a firmness level up front.
A strong alternative
Saatva Classican innerspring option if neither foam nor hybrid feels right
- 365-night home trial
- Free white-glove delivery and old-mattress removal
- Lifetime warranty
- Three comfort levels and two mattress heights
Which mattress should you choose between Puffy and Brooklyn Bedding?
Pick the Puffy Mattress if you want a classic memory foam feel: a medium-firm, body-adapting surface with a soft breathable knit cover that stays cool to the touch. Pick the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid if you want coils under you, a choice of three firmness levels, and a construction built around edge-to-edge support. Both come with a 365-night trial and a lifetime or limited lifetime warranty, so the trial terms will not decide this for you. The deciding factor is feel and construction, not policy.
Who is the Puffy Mattress for?
The Puffy Mattress suits sleepers who want memory foam and nothing else in the comfort layer. It is built with six layers and a medium-firm feel, and Puffy describes it as cradling back support with body-adapting memory foam. The cover is a soft, breathable knit that the brand calls cool to the touch, and the mattress is positioned as less motion transfer friendly for couples who share a bed. It is the simpler product of the two: one feel, one construction, no firmness decision to make at checkout. If you already know you like the slow, contouring hug of memory foam and you sleep on your back or side, this is the profile that fits. If you are still weighing foam against coils, our best memory foam mattresses for 2026 lays out that wider field.
Who is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid for?
The Signature Hybrid is for sleepers who want a spring system in the build and control over firmness. Brooklyn Bedding offers it in soft, medium, and firm, and the brand maps those choices to sleep positions: soft for side sleepers, medium for combination sleepers, firm for back and stomach sleepers. The construction is 13.25 inches tall in seven layers without the pillowtop, or 14 inches tall in eight layers with it, and it uses 8-inch Ascension X coils with 3.5 inches of comfort foam. The brand highlights solid edge-to-edge support, motion isolation from the encased coils, and a ThermoPhase foam layer with phase change material. It is the more configurable of the two products, and it is the one to consider if you move between positions at night. Shoppers comparing coil builds should also look at our best hybrid mattresses for 2026.
How do the two mattresses compare side by side?
The table below lines up what each brand states about its own product. Where a figure is not given, the cell says so rather than guessing.
| Attribute | Puffy Mattress | Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Memory foam | Hybrid, foam over encased coils |
| Feel | Medium-firm, body-adapting | Soft, medium, or firm |
| Layers | 6 layers | 7 layers without pillowtop, 8 with |
| Height | – | 13.25 inches without pillowtop, 14 inches with |
| Trial | 365 nights | 365 nights |
| Warranty | Lifetime warranty | Limited lifetime warranty |
| Shipping | Ships in 1 to 2 days, free shipping and free returns | Ships in 5 to 8 business days, free shipping |
| Queen price | – | Queen: $1,465 |
Which feel and support level fits your sleep position?
Firmness is where the two products diverge most sharply. Puffy offers a single medium-firm feel across the mattress, so your position choice has to fit the mattress rather than the other way around. Brooklyn Bedding lets you choose, and it tells you which firmness matches which position: soft for side sleepers, medium for combination sleepers, firm for back and stomach sleepers. That makes the Signature Hybrid the more forgiving purchase for someone unsure of their preference, and for couples who do not agree. Puffy’s single feel is a strength if you already know medium-firm memory foam is what you want, and a risk if you do not. For a wider look at position-specific picks, our best mattresses for side sleepers for 2026 covers that decision in depth.
What are the mattresses made of?
Puffy describes the Mattress as six layers of memory foam under a soft, breathable knit cover, with the whole build aimed at cradling back support. The brand does not break out individual layer materials on the page, so the honest summary is a straightforward all-foam construction with a medium-firm tune. Brooklyn Bedding is more specific: pressure-relieving quilt foam, high-density foam, premium steel coils assembled in-house, and copper-infused foam for heat dispersion. The coil system is 8 inches of Ascension X coils paired with 3.5 inches of comfort foam, and the foam is CertiPUR-US certified. If you want to see how these two constructions sit against the broader foam category, our best memory foam mattresses for 2026 is the natural next read.
See the Saatva Classic price in your size →
Which mattress sleeps cooler?
Both brands put cooling front and center, but they approach it differently. Puffy’s claim is a soft, breathable knit cover that is cool to the touch, working with an all-foam build. Brooklyn Bedding layers several features: a ThermoPhase foam with phase change material that absorbs and releases heat, a GlacioTex cooling cover with cool-to-the-touch top fabric, copper-infused foam for heat dispersion, and a moisture-wicking quilt foam. The optional Cloud Cooling Pillow Top adds a dual layer of pillowtop foam on top of the GlacioTex cover. If temperature is your main worry, the Signature Hybrid has the longer list of stated cooling features, while Puffy’s approach is simpler and cover-led. Our best cooling mattresses for 2026 rounds up other options in this category.
How do trial, warranty and shipping compare?
The trial periods match exactly: both brands give you 365 nights at home. Warranty wording differs slightly, with Puffy stating a lifetime warranty and Brooklyn Bedding stating a limited lifetime warranty, so read the terms of whichever you choose before buying. Shipping also differs in pace. Puffy ships in 1 to 2 days with free shipping and free returns and a 100% money-back guarantee. Brooklyn Bedding ships free in 5 to 8 business days, with roll-packed boxes delivered to your door, and notes HSA/FSA eligibility for qualified customers. Neither brand’s page here describes in-room setup or old mattress removal, so if white-glove service matters to you, that is a reason to look at the Saatva alternative below.
What does each mattress cost?
Brooklyn Bedding publishes a full size chart for the Signature Hybrid: Twin $959, Twin XL $1,165, Full $1,332, Queen $1,465, King $1,865, Cal King $1,865. The Puffy page in front of us does not publish a queen figure, so no price comparison can be drawn from these two pages, and none should be. Value here is better judged on what you get: Puffy gives you a six-layer all-foam build with a 365-night trial and lifetime warranty, while Brooklyn Bedding gives you coils, three firmness choices, an optional cooling pillowtop, and the same 365-night trial with a limited lifetime warranty. Brooklyn Bedding also notes a promotional code on its page, but promotional pricing changes and should not drive the decision.
Who should NOT buy these mattresses?
Skip the Puffy Mattress if you need a firmness choice, if you sleep primarily on your stomach and want a firm surface, or if you want coils in the build. Its single medium-firm feel and all-foam construction will not suit those needs. Skip the Signature Hybrid if you specifically want the slow contouring of memory foam with no springs underneath, if you prefer a simple one-feel purchase, or if you want a mattress that ships faster than 5 to 8 business days. Neither mattress is the right answer for someone who wants in-room delivery and old mattress removal, since neither page describes that service.
Is the Saatva Classic a better alternative?
The Saatva Classic is an innerspring mattress with a 3-inch Euro pillow top, a dual-coil design built from triple-tempered recycled carbon steel coils, and patented Lumbar Zone technology for spinal alignment. It comes in three comfort levels, Plush Soft at 3 out of 10, Luxury Firm at 5 to 7 out of 10, and Firm at 8 out of 10, and in two heights, 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches. That is a wider firmness range than either product above, and it is paired with free white-glove delivery that includes in-room setup and removal of your old mattress, plus a 365-night home trial and a lifetime warranty. The cover is a breathable organic cotton blend treated with Guardin botanical antimicrobial treatment, and the foams are CertiPUR-US certified with GREENGUARD Gold certification. If you want a hotel-bed feel with coils and full service delivery, the Classic is the alternative to price against both products in this comparison.
Verdict: the Puffy Mattress wins for sleepers who want a pure memory foam feel with a single medium-firm tune and a soft cool-to-the-touch cover, while the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid wins for sleepers who want coils, a choice of soft, medium or firm, and a longer list of stated cooling features. Choose Puffy if you already love memory foam and want the simplest purchase. Choose the Signature Hybrid if you move between positions, share the bed, or care about edge-to-edge coil support. If neither construction feels right and you want in-room setup, the Saatva Classic is the alternative worth a look.
A strong alternative
Saatva Classiccoils, three comfort levels, white-glove delivery
- 365-night home trial
- Free in-room delivery and old mattress removal
- Lifetime warranty
- 11.5 inch and 14.5 inch heights
World Sleep Almanac score: 7.9/10
Our editorial score for this matchup, judged on five criteria: price at equal size, trial and return terms, warranty wording, materials and construction transparency, and public customer reviews. Both products score well on trial length and warranty, the Signature Hybrid gains on stated construction detail and firmness choice, and Puffy gains on shipping speed and a simpler purchase. The score is editorial and is explained on our rating methodology page.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Puffy Mattress come in more than one firmness?
No. The Puffy Mattress is offered in a single medium-firm feel. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the one that gives you a choice, with soft, medium and firm options mapped to side, combination, and back or stomach sleepers.
How tall is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid?
It stands 13.25 inches tall in seven layers without the pillowtop, and 14 inches tall in eight layers with the pillowtop added. Puffy does not state a height for the Mattress on the page reviewed here.
Which mattress ships faster?
Puffy states that its mattress ships in 1 to 2 days, while Brooklyn Bedding states 5 to 8 business days for the Signature Hybrid. Both ship free.
Can I add a cooling cover to either mattress?
Brooklyn Bedding offers an optional GlacioTex cooling cover and a Cloud Cooling Pillow Top upgrade on the Signature Hybrid. Puffy’s cooling story is built into the standard soft, breathable knit cover described as cool to the touch.
Does either mattress come with a sleep trial?
Both do. Puffy offers 365 nights at home with a 100% money-back guarantee, and Brooklyn Bedding offers a 365-night trial on the Signature Hybrid.
Reviewed by the World Sleep Almanac editorial team. Updated October 2026.
Keep comparing
- Brooklyn Bedding Signature Review: Value or Saatva Service?
- Amerisleep AS3 vs Brooklyn Bedding: Which Foam or Coil Wins
- Puffy Mattresses Review: Great Trial, Four Models to Sort
- Puffy vs Zenhaven: Memory Foam or Flippable Latex?
- Best Luxury Mattress 2026: Saatva Classic Leads, PlushBeds Second
- Best Cooling Mattress 2026: Saatva Latex Hybrid First, Sweetnight Second
- Layla Memory Foam vs Saatva Zenhaven: Which Should You Buy?
- DreamCloud vs Saatva Zenhaven: Which Mattress Wins for You